Published Jul 29, 2016
Looking back at the Class of 2009
Louie Vaccher  •  WildcatReport
Publisher
Twitter
@WildcatReport

Pat Fitzgerald celebrated his 10th anniversary as Northwestern's head coach earlier this month. With that in mind, WildcatReport looks back on the Fitz Era by breaking down his recruiting classes on Fitz Flashback Fridays.

The story of Northwestern’s Class of 2009 is one of extremes.

There were some outstanding players in the group - Jeff Budzien, Damien Proby, Tyler Scott and Patrick Ward form as strong of a quartet as any class. Yet as a whole the group probably had more misses than head coach Pat Fitzgerald has ever had. We ranked nine, or one-half, of the 18 players as Overvalued, meaning that they didn't live up to their potential in purple. Injuries also derailed a few careers before they really got started.

Fitzgerald landed his first four-star (Ward) in this class, which was ranked 62nd in the nation by Rivals. Yet of his four three-stars with the highest 5.7 Rivals Rating (Davon Custis, Proby, Will Studlien and Evan Watkins), only Proby panned out.

Here's a look back at Fitzgerald's third class in Evanston.


Class Superlatives

Head of the Class: Tyler Scott. This was a close one, as we gave the nod to the defensive end by a nose over three-year starting tackle Ward. Scott was just a skinny, 220-pound, two-star prospect from Warren (Ohio) Howland with a couple MAC offers when he committed to Northwestern in November of 2008. But very few players had the work ethic and motor of Scott. He transformed his body into a 265-pound jackhammer and became a mainstay on the edge for the Wildcats, starting all 25 games of his final two seasons. He was named defensive MVP in 2012 and team MVP in 2013, when he was a team co-captain.

Honor Roll: Budzien, simply put, was the best kicker in NU history; Proby is often overlooked but was a stud middle linebacker; and Ward lived up to the hype as Fitzgerald's first four-star recruit.

Biggest Surprises: Scott and Budzien were both two-star prospects.


The Rundown

Northwestern's Class of 2009
NameStarsSkinnyVerdict
3

Appeared in just seven games in career and recorded just one tackle

Overvalued

2

Holds every important school kicking record; 2-time B1G kicker of year and All-America in 2013

Undervalued

3

Maybe the biggest bust of Fitz era, highly sought after recruit played in just four games in career

Overvalued

3

Looked like Tyrell Sutton's heir apparent early, then got benched and eventually transferred to play baseball

Incomplete

3

Special teams player and backup started just one game in career

Overvalued

2

Redshirted freshman year and then transferred for personal reasons

Incomplete

3

Showed promise as freshman but tore ACL as soph and injuries limited him to five games over last two years

Overvalued

2

Created sensation as recruit, when he came out of nowhere to earn camp offer, but not as a player, with just 4 catches

Overvalued

3

Played in just five games in career as a reserve

Overvalued

2

Saw time on special teams and as reserve in two years before injuries forced retirement

Incomplete

3

Underrated MLB started last 32 games of career; leading tackler and honorable mention All-B1G in 2011, '12

About right

LB/SB Tim Riley

2

Special teams stalwart eventually found home at superback and saw increased role

About right

2

Biggest steal of class named defensive MVP as junior and team MVP as senior; ranks 6th all-time in sacks

Undervalued

3

Never cracked two-deep on OL, moved to superback and played in short yardage; made one start

Overvalued

3

NU gambled on recruit with severe high school ACL tear and lost; played just three games in career

Overvalued

3

Hard runner was valuable contributor as reserve and spot starter; overcame ACL tear as RS soph

About right

4

Played as true freshman, started 39 games, made tough transition from right to left tackle as senior

About right

3

Highly-ranked QB got shot as starter in 2010 and was overmatched; eventually moved to superback

Overvalued